If our governing class were competent and had some sense of noblesse oblige, we might see a program like this instituted. Of course, they are incompetent and ignoble. Result: problem people (those with negative economic value under our current system) become more problematic--and their problems become contagious, instead of being contained and ameliorated.
The second discussion is less simple, much-much much-much longer, more entertaining and intelligent--and more realistic in assessing the likely elite response to the "dire problem":
Perhaps he overestimates the difficulty of solving the problem under the current dispensation. Paperwork may easily be created for anyone who can even marginally read--what do you think our regulators do other than create mostly superfluous paperwork requirements? The problem is the failure of our Marxist overlords to make clear the distinction between the lifestyles of workers and those of welfare cases. They prefer to integrate these opposing types into "diverse" communities with virtually identical effective incomes. The bottom quarter or so of our society has insufficient incentive to work. And this temptation to idleness is inflicted upon precisely those limited human types who are least capable of independently discovering the value of work, its saving characteristic of offering a point, a goal to the life beyond crude hedonism and recreational criminality. The Marxists, being atheists, ought to understand this issue all the more clearly for their lack of supernatural faith--which is one of the other two main sources of purpose in human life, along with family. But, at best, their idealistic preconceptions foreclose any such insight. At worst, they're playing a most cynical political game. Make-work is thus the most realistic of the solutions on offer to save the increasing numbers of economically useless Americans from degeneration. The guaranteed income idea above is one well-considered form of this make-work option. It would likely produce lower birth rates among the make-workers as well, a happy Darwinian benefit.
No comments:
Post a Comment